Carisolv化学机械法治疗乳牙龋病效果的Meta分析

doi:10.13481/j.1671-587X.20210320

Abstract

Abstract: Objective

To explore the effect of Carisolv chemomechanical method in treatment of deciduous tooth caries in the children， and to provide the evidence-based medical basis for the extensive application of this method in the clinical practice.

Methods

PubMed， CNKI， Medline， Wiley Online Library， Wanfang and Weipu databases were searched by computer from inception to October 31，2020.Meta-analysis was conducted on the complete randomized controlled trials that met the inclusion criteria.

Results

A total of 11 completely randomized controlled trials involving 1 051 teeth of 645 patients were included. The painless rate of Carisolv chemomechanical method was significantly higher than other traditional methods（OR=4.84，95%CI：3.44－6.81，Z=9.04，P<0.01），and the incidence of postoperative complications of the patients treated with Carisolv chemomechanical method were lower than those of other traditional methods （RR=0.37，95%CI： 0.21－0.63，Z=3.60，P=0.0003）.The pediatric patients were more inclined to Carisolv chemomechanical method when choosing the retreatment method， but the difference in preference was not statistically significant（OR=16.99，95% CI：1.50－192.31，Z=2.29，P=0.02）.

Conclusion

The pediatric patients treated with Carisolv chemomechanical method are less likely to suffer from pain and complications， and this method is more likely to be accepted by the children. Carisolv is a suitable technique for the caries of children’s deciduous teeth.

Key words: Carisolv, chemomechanical method, deciduous tooth, caries, Meta-analysis

CLC Number:

R781.1

Yuan ZHAO, Dayong LIU, Yong TIAN, Dabing BAI. Effect of Carisolv chemomechanical method in treatment of deciduous tooth caries: A Meta-analysis[J].Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2021, 47(3): 694-700.

Figures/Tables 6

Tab.1

Tab.2

Fig. 1

Fig. 2

Fig. 3

Fig. 4

References

1	冯希平. 中国居民口腔健康状况：第四次中国口腔健康流行病学调查报告［C］//中华医学会口腔预防医学专业委员会.2018年中华口腔医学会第十八次口腔预防医学学术年会论文汇编. 西安：中华医学会口腔预防医学专业委员会， 2018：13-14.
2	田璧君，秦满. 儿童乳牙龋与第一恒磨牙患龋风险相关性的研究进展［J］.北京口腔医学，2020，28（1）： 55-57.
3	刘万颖，戴丽娜.儿童牙科畏惧症发生原因调查分析［J］. 口腔医学研究， 2019， 35（2）： 185-188.
4	BERGMANN J， LEIT?O J， KULTJE C， et al. Removing dentine caries in deciduous teeth with Carisolv： a randomised， controlled， prospective study with six-month follow-up， comparing chemomechanical treatment with drilling［J］. Oral Health Prev Dent， 2005， 3（2）： 105-111.
5	陈小贤，葛立宏. Carisolv化学机械去腐技术的临床应用评价［J］. 实用口腔医学杂志， 2006， 22（1）： 80-82.
6	LOZANO-CHOURIO M A， ZAMBRANO O， GONZáLEZ H， et al. Clinical randomized controlled trial of chemomechanical caries removal （Carisolv）［J］. Int J Paediatr Dent， 2006， 16（3）： 161-167.
7	KIRZIOGLU Z， GURBUZ T， YILMAZ Y. Clinical evaluation of chemomechanical and mechanical caries removal： status of the restorations at 3， 6， 9 and 12 months［J］. Clin Oral Investig， 2007， 11（1）： 69-76.
8	HEGDE S， KAKTI A， BOLAR D R， et al. Clinical efficiency of three caries removal systems： rotary excavation， carisolv， and papacarie［J］. J Dent Child （Chic）， 2016， 83（1）： 22-28.
9	吉光柱，樊宏.儿童乳牙龋齿治疗中伢典微创凝胶去龋技术的应用效果研究［J］. 中国保健营养，2017，27（5）： 349.
10	张霞霞. 伢典凝胶与传统牙钻去腐对乳磨牙深龋患儿疼痛及意外穿髓的影响［J］.甘肃医药，2018，37（7）：600-602.
11	MOIMAZ S A S， OKAMURA A Q C，LIMA D C，et al. Clinical and microbiological analysis of mechanical and chemomechanical methods of caries removal in deciduous teeth［J］. Oral Health Prev Dent， 2019， 17（3）： 283-288.
12	宋莉秋.Carisolv Ⅲ凝胶微创法与传统牙钻去龋法治疗小儿乳磨牙深龋的效果比较［J］. 中国民康医学， 2020， 32（13）： 125-127.
13	安伟，赵景杰，魏德增. 采用伢典微创凝胶去龋治疗儿童龋齿的效果分析及研究［J］. 健康大视野， 2020（17）： 69.
14	陈静文.微创技术用于治疗乳牙龋齿的临床评价［J］. 养生保健指南，2020（11）： 74-75.
15	黄朝阳，林永杰.微创无痛伢碘去腐技术在龋齿治疗中的应用效果分析［J］. 中国基层医药， 2018， 25（19）： 2475-2477.
16	唐世洁，唐世平，葛风华，等. 三代伢典微创技术在乳牙深龋治疗中的应用效果［J］. 中国现代药物应用， 2018， 12（19）： 28-30.
17	汪婷婷，李虎.Carisolv去龋效果的体外研究［J］. 世界最新医学信息文摘（连续型电子期刊）， 2020， 20（48）： 7-8.
18	ALI A H， KOLLER G， FOSCHI F， et al. Self-limiting versus conventional caries removal： a randomized clinical trial［J］. J Dent Res， 2018， 97（11）： 1207-1213.
19	尚琼，夏烨鹏，杨颜菁.乳牙化学机械去龋的临床应用研究［J］. 口腔医学， 2018， 38（5）： 449-452.
20	汪大照，余志芬. N₂O镇静联合Carisolv微创去龋对牙科焦虑症儿童的临床应用［J］. 吉林医学， 2019， 40（11）： 2493-2496.
21	王海男，李云华.伢典去龋法在龋病治疗中的应用［J］. 牙体牙髓牙周病学杂志， 2011， 21（8）： 478-480.
22	赵树玲，吴凡，焦正凯.伢典微创去龋法治疗乳磨牙龋的临床观察［J］. 蚌埠医学院学报，2020， 45（4）： 469-471.
23	李艳，赵今，吴泰相，等.Carisolv化学机械去龋技术治疗乳牙龋病效果的系统评价［J］. 牙体牙髓牙周病学杂志， 2011， 21（8）： 459-464.
24	王云，叶鹏，王凤艳，等.化学机械法与传统牙钻法去腐效果对比的Meta分析［J］. 北京口腔医学， 2020， 28（2）： 94-99.
25	张静，王彩霞.儿童牙科焦虑症的相关因素分析及研究进展［J］.世界最新医学信息文摘（连续型电子期刊），2020，20（13）：25-26.
26	张美蓉.儿童牙科畏惧症的心理诱导方法［J］. 山西医药杂志， 2020， 49（19）： 2684-2685.
27	CARDOSO M， COELHO A，RUI L M， et al. Efficacy and patient's acceptance of alternative methods for caries removal-a systematic review［J］. J Clin Med， 2020， 9（11）： E3407.
28	姚敏，龚爱秀，周淑，等.伢典Ⅲ凝胶微创去腐治疗乳牙龋齿对患儿心理影响［J］. 医学研究生学报， 2019， 32（2）： 167-170.
29	付强，刘艳，王鹏，等.渗透树脂衬洞对复合树脂充填体微渗漏及牙本质粘接界面超微结构的影响［J］. 实用口腔医学杂志， 2020， 36（2）： 303-306.
30	ERTüRK AVUNDUK A T， BA?LAR S. Evaluation of microleakage in class v cavities prepared by different caries removal methods［J］. Microsc Res Tech， 2019， 82（9）： 1566-1574.

Study	Sample	Tooth	T/C	Intervention	Outcome indication	Follow-up time
BERGMANN,et al.^[4]	46	92	46/46	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①②③	6 months
CHEN,et al.^[5]	32	64	32/32	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①②③	6 months
LOZANO CHOURIO,et al.^[6]	40	80	40/40	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①③	Not described
KIRZIOGLU,et al.^[7]	28	56	28/28	T:Carisolv C:Excavation	①	1 year
HEGDE,et al.^[8]	50	100	50/50	T:Carisolv C:Drill	③	Not described
JI,et al.^[9]	92	92	46/46	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①②	1 year
ZHANG,et al.^[10]	84	168	84/84	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①②	1 year
MOIMAZ,et al.^[11]	16	32	16/16	T:Carisolv C:Excavation	①	Not described
SONG,et al.^[12]	60	186	92/94	T:Carisolv C:Drill	②	6 months
AN,et al.^[13]	88	88	44/44	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①	Not described
CHEN,et al.^[14]	93	93	47/46	T:Carisolv C:Drill	①	Not described

Study	Random method	Allocation concealment	Performance bias	detection bias	Attrition bias	Reporting bias	Other bias
BERGMANN,et al.^[4]	Sealed random envelopes	L	L	?	L	L	L
CHEN,et al.^[5]	Turn coins	?	L	?	L	L	L
LOZANO-CHOURIO,et al.^[6]	Turn coins	?	L	?	L	L	L
KIRZIOGLU,et al.^[7]	Random envelopes with serial numbers	L	L	?	L	L	L
HEGDE,et al.^[8]	Random number table	?	L	?	L	L	L
JI,et al.^[9]	Computer randomization	L	L	?	L	L	L
ZHANG,et al.^[10]	Random number table	?	L	?	L	L	L
MOIMAZ,et al.^[11]	Computer random number generator	L	L	?	L	L	L
SONG,et al.^[12]	Random number table	?	L	?	L	L	L
AN,et al.^[13]	Random draw	?	L	?	L	L	L
CHEN,et al.^[14]	Stochastic comprehensive equilibrium method	?	L	?	L	L	L

[1]	Yinxia TAI,Han ZHANG,Lei YU,Xianchun ZHU. Changes in levels of inflammatory factors in gingival crevicular fluid of patients with periodontal disease before and after invisible appliance：A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2025, 51(1): 182-190.
[2]	Peng QI,Xianying MENG,Meihua PIAO,Qiang ZHANG. Network Meta-analysis on risk factors of recurrence of papillary thyroid microcarcinoma [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2023, 49(6): 1504-1512.
[3]	Yuanhang ZHAO,Linlin YAN,Jiazhuo SONG,Xinying ZOU,Hong ZHAO,Xin LIU,Jiawen CHEN,Yiyan YU,Zhimin ZHANG,Hong ZHANG. Preparation and properties of strontium and nitrogen co-doped titanium dioxide/nano hydroxyapatite composites resins [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2023, 49(4): 1067-1075.
[4]	Guangcai WAN,Hongshuai SUN,Hua ZHU,Xiuyan YU. Effect of NLR and PLR on prognosis of small-cell lung cancer patients received platinum-based first-line chemotherapy: A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2021, 47(5): 1264-1272.
[5]	Guangcai WAN,Hongshuai SUN,Hua ZHU,Xiuyan YU. Meta-analysis on relationship between neutrophil/lymphocyte ratio and prognosis of patients with non-small cell lung cancer treated with EGFR-TKIs [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2020, 46(6): 1267-1273.
[6]	YU Xiuyan, WAN Guangcai, SUN Hongshuai, ZHU Hua, GAO Haiyan, WU Xuefeng. Relationship between fibrinogen and prognosis of breast cancer patients:A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2019, 45(05): 1092-1097.
[7]	ZHENG Taijing, BAI Yuanliang, ZHENG Jiawen, LIU Honghong, GUO Zijun, WANG Ping. Efficacies of clarithromycin and metronidazole in treatment of chronic periodontitis: A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2019, 45(01): 130-136.
[8]	LU Mingyue, LI Jing. Relationships between expression of IGF-1 in cancer tissue of gastric cancer patients and clinicopathological parameters in China: A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2019, 45(01): 137-142.
[9]	QI Lu, BAI Wei, YU Weiying, LI Yuanyuan, HUA Wanqing, KOU Changgui. Randomized controlled trials for curative effect of saxagliptin combined with insulin in treatment of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Medicine Edition), 2018, 44(06): 1235-1242.
[10]	NIU Huikun, QU Yangming, LI Meiqi, LI Lu, LYU Xin, SONG Yuanyuan, GAO Chunshi, LI Bo. Meta-analysis on efficacy and adverse effects of neoadjuvant chemotherapy combined with capecitabine in treatment of breast cancer [J]. Journal of Jilin University Medicine Edition, 2017, 43(06): 1171-1176.
[11]	YAO Yanan, YAO Hua, YAN Duoduo, LYU Kejia, GONG Lijun, WANG Guohua. Meta-analysis on correlation between oral lichen planus and Candida albicans infection [J]. Journal of Jilin University Medicine Edition, 2017, 43(05): 967-974.
[12]	NIU Meng, DENG Dayong, LI Yunpengfei, LIU Shuo, DING Jun. Values of MRE in diagnosis of stages of hepatic fibrosis:A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University Medicine Edition, 2017, 43(04): 787-793.
[13]	MA Ranyang, YU Hong, WANG Xin. Evaluation on clinical efficacy of hyperbaric oxygenation in treatment of sudden deafness:A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University Medicine Edition, 2017, 43(02): 298-305.
[14]	ZHANG Yang, WANG Junfeng, CAOHongyan, QIN Ling, XU Guoliang. Effectiveness and safety of Dengzhanhuasu and Dansheng Injection in treatment of patients with angina pectoris of coronary heart disease:A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University Medicine Edition, 2017, 43(02): 317-321.
[15]	XU Jin, CHEN Huaiji, XU Feng, WANG Qi, ZHANG Yuezhu, LIU Hongbo, ZHANG Tianrong, YE Lin. Association between phthalate ester exposure and population obesity:A Meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Jilin University Medicine Edition, 2017, 43(02): 306-310.

Effect of Carisolv chemomechanical method in treatment of deciduous tooth caries: A Meta-analysis

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Like

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 6

References

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 10