Journal of Jilin University(Earth Science Edition) ›› 2021, Vol. 51 ›› Issue (5): 1400-1407.doi: 10.13278/j.cnki.jjuese.20210017

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Accuracy of Drag Force Models in the CFD-DEM Method

Peng Kairan1,2, Liu Hongshuai1,2, Ping Xinyu1,2, Cheng Kuang1,2   

  1. 1. College of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Hebei University, Baoding 071000, Hebei, China;
    2. Institute of Geotechnical Engineering, Hebei University, Baoding 071000, Hebei, China
  • Received:2021-01-18 Online:2021-09-26 Published:2021-09-29
  • Supported by:
    Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (52009025) and the Natural Science Foundation of Hebei Province (E2020201013, E2020201017)

Abstract: The CFD-DEM coupling method has been widely used in the modelling of fluid-solid interactions in geotechnical engineering. The accuracy of the CFD-DEM modelling is strongly influenced by the precision of the drag force models used to deal with particle-fluid interactions. In this study, the sedimentation of a single particle in water was modeled by using the CFD-DEM method, three typical drag force models and various particle sizes were considered in the simulations, the terminal sedimentation velocities of particles were obtained in the simulations and then compared with those predicted by a popular empirical model, and the influence of the particle Reynolds number (Rep) on the accuracy of the drag force models was analyzed. The results show that the accuracies of both the Ergun, Wen and Yu model and the Di Felice model decrease, while the accuracy of the Hill and Koch model firstly increases and then decreases with the increasing of Rep. Generally, when Rep ≤ 14 and Rep>72, the relative magnitudes of the accuracy of the three drag force models are as follows:Ergun, Wen and Yu model>Di Felice model>Hill and Koch model; However, when 14<Rep ≤ 40, Hill and Koch model has the highest accuracy, while the Di Felice model has the lowest accuracy; When 40<Rep ≤ 72, the relative magnitudes of the accuracy of the three drag force models are Ergun, Wen and Yu model > Hill and Koch model > Di Felice model.

Key words: discrete element method(DEM), computational fluid dynamics (CFD), drag force models, single particle sedimentation

CLC Number: 

  • TU46
[1] 季顺迎.计算颗粒力学及工程应用[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 2018. Ji Shunying. Computational Granular Mechanics and Its Engineering Applications[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 2018.
[2] Cundall P A, Strack O D L. A Discrete Numerical Model for Granular Assemblies[J]. Géotechnique, 1979, 29(1):47-65.
[3] Tsuji Y, Kawaguchi T, Tanaka T. Discrete Particle Simulation of Two-Dimensional Fluidized Bed[J]. Powder Technology, 1993, 77(1):79-87.
[4] El Shamy U, Zeghal M. Coupled Continum Discrete Model for Saturated Granular Soils[J]. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2005, 131(4):413-426.
[5] El Shamy U, Zeghal M. A Micro-Mechanical Investigation of the Dynamic Response and Liquefaction of Saturated Granular Soils[J]. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 2007, 27:712-729.
[6] Zhao J, Shan T. Coupled CFD-DEM Simulation of Fluid-Particle Interaction in Geomechanics[J]. Powder Technology, 2013, 239:248-258.
[7] 蒋明镜, 张望城. 一种考虑流体状态方程的土体CFD-DEM耦合数值方法[J]. 岩土工程学报, 2013, 36(5):793-801. Jiang Mingjing, Zhang Wangcheng. Coupled CFD-DEM Method for Soils Incorporating Equation of State for Liquid[J]. Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 2013, 36(5):793-801.
[8] 洪勇, 李子睿, 唐少帅, 等.平均粒径对砂土剪切特性的影响及细观机理[J]. 吉林大学学报(地球科学版), 2020, 50(6):1814-1822. Hong Yong, Li Zirui, Tang Shaoshuai, et al. Effect of Average Particle Size on Shear Properties of Sand and Its Mesomechanical Analysis[J]. Journal of Jilin University (Earth Science Edition), 2020, 50(6):1814-1822.
[9] 周健, 周凯敏, 姚志雄, 等. 砂土管涌-滤层防治的离散元数值模拟[J]. 水利学报, 2010, 41(1):17-24. Zhou Jian, Zhou Kaimin, Yao Zhixiong, et al. Numerical Simulation of Piping-Filter Prevention in Sandy Soil by Discrete Element Method[J]. Chinese Journal of Water Resources, 2010, 41(1):17-24.
[10] 程旷. 基于离散元的渗流致断级配土颗粒运移数值分析方法研究[D].大连:大连理工大学, 2019. Cheng Kuang.Study on DEM-Based Numerical Methods for Seepage-Induced Fine Particle Migration in Gap-Graded Soils[D]. Dalian:Dalian University of Technology, 2019.
[11] Ergun S. Fluid Flow Through Packed Columns[J]. Chemical Engineering Progress, 1952, 48:89-94.
[12] 吴野. 天然岩土颗粒材料液体中拖曳力系数试验研究[D].大连:大连理工大学, 2017. Wu Ye.Experimental Study on the Drag Force Coefficient of Natural Geotechnical Particle Materials in the Liquid[D]. Dalian:Dalian University of Technology, 2017.
[13] Di Felice R. The Voidage Function for Fluid-Particle Interaction Systems[J]. International Journal of Multiphase Flow, 1994, 20(1):153-159.
[14] Hill R J, Koch D L, Ladd A J C. Moderate-Reynolds-Number Flows in Ordered and Random Arrays of Spheres[J]. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 2001, 448:243-278.
[15] Guo Y, Yu X B. Comparison of the Implementation of Three Common Types of Coupled CFD-DEM Model for Simulating Soil Surface Erosion[J]. International Journal of Multiphase Flow, 2017, 91:89-100.
[16] Zhao J, Shan T. Coupled CFD-DEM Simulation of Fluid-Particle Interaction in Geomechanics[J]. Powder Technology, 2013, 239:248-258.
[17] Hu Z, Zhang Y, Yang Z. Suffusion-Induced Deformation and Microstructural Change of Granular Soils:A Coupled CFD-DEM Study[J]. Acta Geotechnica, 2019, 14(1):795-814.
[18] Vaibhav A, Yogesh S, hah M T, et al. Effect of Drag Models on CFD-DEM Predictions of Bubbling Fluidized Beds with Geldart D Particles[J]. Advanced Powder Technology, 2018, 29:S0921883118303212.
[19] Wdfa B, Jm A. CFD-DEM Solution Verification:Fixed-Bed Studies[J]. Powder Technology, 2018, 339:760-764.
[20] Wen C Y, Yu Y H. A Generalized Method for Predicting the Minimum Fluidization Velocity[J]. AIChE Journal, 1966, 12(3):610-612.
[21] Cheng K, Wang Y, Yang Q, et al. Determination of Microscopic Parameters of Quartz Sand Through Tri-Axial Test Using the Discrete Element Method[J]. Computers and Geotechnics, 2017, 92:22-40.
[22] Cheng K, Wang Y, Yang Q. A Semi-Resolved CFD-DEM Model for Seepage-Induced Fine Particle Migration in Gap-Graded Soils[J]. Computers and Geotechnics, 2018, 100:30-51.
[23] Kloss C, Goniva C, Hager A, et al. Models, Algorithms and Validation for Opensource DEM and CFD-DEM[J]. Progress in Computational Fluid Dynamics:An International Journal, 2012, 12(2/3):140-152.
[24] Brown P P, Lawler D F. Sphere Drag and Settling Velocity Revisited[J]. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 2003, 129(3):222-231.
No related articles found!
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] TANG Jie, L Chuan, LI Zhao-yang, WANG Chen-ye, ZHANG Jing-cheng,LI Hai-yi. Evaluation of Eco-Environmental Quality Based on Coupling of Gray-Clustering and 3S Method-A Case Study on Da’an, Jilin Province[J]. J4, 2008, 38(6): 1037 -1043 .
[2] SHU Long-cang, LI Wei. Analysis on the Stochastic Characteristic of the Hydrauic Conductivity of Bottom Stratum, Beitang Reservoir, Tianjin City[J]. J4, 2007, 37(2): 216 -0220 .
[3] WANG Jin-sheng,TENG Yan-guo,WU Dong-jie. Numerical Simulation Model of Immobile Water and Non-Equilibrium Sorption on the Solute Transport-MIENESOR[J]. J4, 2007, 37(2): 266 -270 .
[4] SU Xiao-si, LIN Xue-yu, DONG Wei-hong, WAN Yu-yu. Application of Inverse Geochemical Modeling in the Correction of Groundwater 14C Dating:advances and Thoughts[J]. J4, 2007, 37(2): 271 -277 .
[5] LIU Hang-jun,LIU Zhi-hong,FENG Yong-jiu, REN Yan-guang, LI Chun-bai. Structural Characteristics and Deformation Sequence of the Urxun Sag in Hailaer Basin, China[J]. J4, 2006, 36(02): 215 -0220 .
[6] YANG Jun-peng, HU Ke, LIU Yu-ying. The Stable Carbon Isotopic Characteristics of Carbonates in Salini alkani Soil in the West Jilin Province[J]. J4, 2006, 36(02): 245 -0249 .
[7] LIU Zhao-shun, SHANG Jin-cheng, XU Wen-liang, JIN Ke. Analysis of Coordinated Development Between Resourceful County Economy and Ecoenvironment in Eastern Jilin Province[J]. J4, 2006, 36(02): 265 -0269 .
[8] LIU Jin-hui, SUN Zhan-xue, SHI Wei-jun. The Discussions on Some Problems of Sandstone Type Uranium Ore by Using Uranium Isotopes[J]. J4, 2006, 36(04): 516 -520 .
[9] LI Xue-ping, TANG Hui-ming. Application of GIS[CD*2]Based Grouped Data Logistic Model in Evaluation of Slope Stability[J]. J4, 2005, 35(03): 361 -0365 .
[10] YANG Chun-mei, LI Hong-qi,LU Da-wei,ZHANG Fang-li,GAO Yuan,SHAO Ying-chao. The Relationship Between Rock Resistivity and Water Saturation in WaterDriveOil and OilDriveWater Process[J]. J4, 2005, 35(05): 667 -671 .