Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition) ›› 2022, Vol. 52 ›› Issue (2): 338-344.doi: 10.13229/j.cnki.jdxbgxb20211147

Previous Articles    

Risk analysis of machining center failure mode based on multi⁃attribute group decision making

Gui-xiang SHEN1,2(),Jun ZHENG1,2,Ying-zhi ZHANG1,2(),Jie SONG1,2,Zhe-wen LI1,2   

  1. 1.Key Laboratory of CNC Equipment Reliability，Ministry of Education，Jilin University，Changchun 130022，China
    2.College of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering，Jilin University，Changchun 130022，China
  • Received:2021-10-30 Online:2022-02-01 Published:2022-02-17
  • Contact: Ying-zhi ZHANG E-mail:shengx@jlu.edu.cn;zhangyz@jlu.edu.cn

RICH HTML

 1   

PDF (PC)

101

Abstract:

Aiming at the problems existing in the traditional FMEA of CNC machine tools， such as the unreasonable distribution of expert weight and risk factor weight， and the insufficient robustness of the calculation model of risk coefficient（RPN）， an improved FMEA method based on multi-attribute group decision-making is proposed. Firstly， interval number is introduced to represent the risk factor of machine tool failure mode； Secondly， considering the subjective and objective weights of experts， according to the consistency principle， the comprehensive weights of experts are calculated， and the weighted average operator（WAA） is used to determine the comprehensive evaluation matrix of fault mode； Thirdly， the interval number entropy method is used to determine the weight of risk factors， and the improved risk priority number （IRPN） calculation model is used to obtain the failure mode risk value； Finally， combined with interval number distance measure， the optimal and worst interval number improved TOPSIS method is used to rank the risk of failure mode. Taking a machining center as an example， the rationality and effectiveness of the method are verified.

Key words: machine tool, failure mode and effect analysis, multi-attribute group decision-making, improved risk priority number, technique for order preference by similarity to an ideal solution

CLC Number: 

  • TG659

Fig.1

Flow chart of improved FMEA method for multi-attribute group decision making"

Fig.2

Iterative process of expert comprehensive weight"

Fig.3

Expert weight iteration diagram"

Fig.4

Deviation degree between experts and groups"

Fig.5

Deviation among experts"

Table 1

Calculation results of closeness"

故障OPRESRIRPNFi
H1［5.4928，6.1592］［6.5194，7.4086］［5.9176，6.6743］0.5966
H2［3.4982，4.3731］［4.3769，5.0072］［3.8563，4.6384］0.0000
H3［8.2417，8.4395］［7.1791，7.9644］［7.7616，8.2294］1.0000
H4［3.7259，4.1042］［6.4459，6.7387］［4.7286，5.0917］0.0507
H5［3.8337，4.2242］［6.5900，7.2762］［4.8519，5.3507］0.0849

H6

H7

H8

H9

H10

H11

H12

H13

H14

［3.7532，3.9995］

［4.1898，4.3029］

［3.8079，3.8709］

［5.4130，6.1102］

［4.6526，5.0433］

［3.6416，4.6526］

［3.5768，3.8921］

［4.5566，5.1622］

［4.5014，5.0735］

［6.3354，6.9485］

［4.8352，5.6408］

［6.8116，7.1112］

［5.8572，6.1702］

［5.1228，5.8277］

［4.5910，5.1108］

［6.1377，6.7498］

［6.5826，7.1726］

［7.0718，7.5394］

［4.7127，5.0850］

［4.4591，4.8404］

［4.9033，5.0426］

［5.6018，6.1363］

［4.8515，5.3705］

［4.0276，4.8465］

［4.5233，4.9447］

［5.3469，5.9558］

［5.4784，6.0269］

0.0488

0.0200

0.0645

0.3791

0.0868

0.0024

0.0271

0.2677

0.3148

Fig.6

Comparison of sorting results"

1 Peeters J F W, Basten R J I, Tinga T. Improving failure analysis efficiency by combining FTA and FMEA in a recursive manners[J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 2018, 172(4): 36-44.
2 Wang Wei-zhong, Liu Xin-wang, Qin Yong, et al. A risk evaluation and prioritization for FMEA with prospect theory and choquet integral[J]. Safety Science, 2018, 110: 152-163.
3 韦可佳, 耿俊豹, 徐孙庆. 基于模糊理论与D-S证据理论的FMEA方法[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2019, 41(11): 2662-2668.
Wei Ke-jia, Geng Jun-bao, Xu Sun-qing. FMEA method based on fuzzy theory and D-S evidence theory[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2019, 41(11): 2662-2668.
4 王晓峰, 申桂香, 张英芝, 等. 基于改进危害度和DEMATEL方法的abc轴进给系统的故障排序[J]. 吉林大学学报: 工学版, 2012, 42(1): 122-127.
Wang Xiao-feng, Shen Gui-xiang,Zhang Ying-zhi,et al. Prioritizing failures of abc-axis feeding systems based on improved criticality and DEMALTEL method[J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2012, 42(1): 122-127.
5 Liu Hu-chen, Li Zhao-jun, Song Wen-yan, et al. Failure mode and effect analysis using cloud model theory and PROMETHEE method[J]. IEEE Transactions on Reliability, 2017, 66(4): 1058-1072.
6 Lo H W, Liou J J H, Chuang Y C, et al. A novel failure mode and effect analysis model for machine tool risk analysis[J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 2019, 183: 173-183.
7 郑玉彬, 申桂香, 张英芝, 等. 基于贝叶斯网络的链式刀库系统重要度分析[J]. 吉林大学学报: 工学版, 2019, 49(2): 466-471.
Zheng Yu-bin, Shen Gui-xiang, Zhang Ying-zhi,et al. Importance analysis of chain-type tool magazine system based on Bayesian network[J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2019, 49(2): 466-471.
8 王晓燕, 申桂香, 张英芝, 等. 基于DEMATEL方法的数控装备故障相关性分析[J]. 吉林大学学报: 工学版, 2012, 42(): 100-103.
Wang Xiao-yan, Shen Gui-xiang, Zhang Ying-zhi, et al. Analysis about failure correlation of CNC equipment base on DEMATEL[J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2012, 42(Sup.1): 100-103.
9 Jiang Guang-jun, Cai Shuang, Zhang Nan, et al. Reliability analysis of the starting and landing system of UAV by FMECA and FTA[J]. Journal of Industrial and Production Engineering, 2019, 36(8): 503-511.
10 Zhao Xiao-song, Chen Te-hung, Kun Zhang, et al. Applying an improved failure mode effect analysis method to evaluate the safety of a three-in-one machine tool[J]. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing & Service Industries, 2020, 30(1): 71-82.
11 Liu Hu-chen, You Jian-xin, You Xiao-yue, et al. Evaluating the risk of healthcare failure modes using interval 2-tuple hybrid weighted distance measure[J]. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 2014, 78(12): 249-258.
12 王睿, 李延来, 朱江洪, 等. 考虑专家共识的改进FMEA风险评估方法[J]. 浙江大学学报: 工学版, 2018, 52(6): 1058-1067.
Wang Rui, Li Yan-lai, Zhu Jiang-hong, et al. Improved FMEA method for risk evaluation considering expert consensus[J]. Journal of Zhejiang University(Engineering Science), 2018, 52(6): 1058-1067.
13 聂文滨, 刘卫东, 汪建东, 等. 基于证据理论和矩阵相似度的工艺失效风险评估[J]. 计算机集成制造系统, 2016, 22(11): 2602-2612.
Nie Wen-bin, Liu Wei-dong, Wang Jian-dong, et al. Evaluation approach in process failure risk based on matrix similarity and evidence theory[J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 2016, 22(11): 2602-2612.
14 安相华, 蔡卫国, 宋晓杰. 基于云模型与协同决策的FMEA耦合评估方法[J]. 计算机集成制造系统, 2018, 24(5): 1179-1190.
An Xiang-hua, Cai Wei-guo, Song Xiao-jie. FMEA coupling evaluation method based on cloud model and collaborative decision[J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 2018, 24(5): 1179-1190.
15 王晓峰, 申桂香, 张英芝, 等. 基于群体决策和多种赋值方式的加工中心关键部件RPN分析[J]. 吉林大学学报: 工学版, 2011, 41(6): 630-635.
Wang Xiao-feng, Shen Gui-xiang, Zhang Ying-zhi, et al. Analysis on risk priority number of critical component of machining center based on group decision-making and various assignment ways[J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2011, 41(6): 630-635.
16 陈晓红, 刘益凡. 基于区间数群决策矩阵的专家权重确定方法及其算法实现[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2010, 32(10): 2128-2131.
Chen Xiao-hong, Liu Yi-fan. Expert weights determination method and realization algorithm based on interval numbers group decision matrices[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2010, 32(10): 2128-2131.
17 王珊珊. 语言模糊多属性群决策中群共识问题研究[D]. 成都: 西南石油大学理学院, 2019.
Wang Shan-shan. Research on group consensus in linguistic fuzzy multi-attribute group decision making[D]. Chengdu: College of Science, Southwest Petroleum University, 2019.
[1] Chuan-hai CHEN,Cheng-gong WANG,Zhao-jun YANG,Zhi-feng LIU,Hai-long TIAN. Research status and development trend analysis of reliability modeling of CNC machine tools [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2022, 52(2): 253-266.
[2] Guo-long LI,Xiao-hui TAO,Kai XU,Zhe-yu LI. Rapid measurement and identification of position dependent geometric errors of CNC machine tool turntable [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2021, 51(2): 458-467.
[3] Hong⁃bin CAI,Guo⁃quan SHI. Tool path generation of slow tool servo for active control machining error [J]. Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), 2019, 49(4): 1221-1227.
[4] ZHENG Yu-bin, YANG Bin, WANG Xiao-feng, SHEN Gui-xiang, ZHAO Xian-zhuo, QIN Meng-meng. Test time design of motorized spindle accelerated life test based on Weibull distribution [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2018, 48(3): 767-772.
[5] SHEN Gui-xiang, ZENG Wen-bin, ZHANG Ying-zhi, WU Mao-kun, ZHENG Yu-bin. Determination of average maintenance time of CNC machine tools under minimum failure rate [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2017, 47(5): 1519-1526.
[6] LIU Ying, ZHANG Kai, YU Xiang-jun. Multi-objective optimization of hydrostatic bearing of hollow shaft based on surrogate model [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2017, 47(4): 1130-1137.
[7] WANG Zhi-yuan, LI Guo-dong, WANG Yong-hua. Optimization decision model for bridge design based on AHP-TOPSIS [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2017, 47(2): 478-482.
[8] ZHANG Ying-zhi, LIU Jin-tong, SHEN Gui-xiang, QI Xiao-yan, LONG Zhe. Reliability modeling of CNC machine tools system based on failure correlation analysis [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2017, 47(1): 169-173.
[9] QU Xing-tian, ZHAO Yong-bing, LIU Hai-zhong, WANG Xin, YANG Xu, CHEN Hang-de. Modeling and experiment of spatial geometric errors of hybrid serial-parallel machine tool [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2017, 47(1): 137-144.
[10] MENG Shu, SHEN Gui-xiang, ZHANG Ying-zhi, LONG Zhe, ZENG Wen-bin. Replacement time of system components of NC machine tools based on time-correlation [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2016, 46(6): 1946-1952.
[11] LI Hong-zhou, YANG Zhao-jun, XU Bin-bin, WANG Yan-kun, JIA Yu-hui, HOU Chao. Design of testing period for reliability assessment of NC machine tools [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2016, 46(5): 1520-1527.
[12] WANG Jian-jian, FENG Ping-fa, ZHANG Jian-fu, WU Zhi-jun, ZHANG Guo-bin, YAN Pei-long. Modeling of centering accuracy of chuck and its maintaining characteristics and restoration method [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2016, 46(2): 487-493.
[13] YANG Zhao-jun, YANG Chuan-gui, CHEN Fei, HAO Qing-bo, ZHENG Zhi-tong, WANG Song. Parameter estimation of reliability model of machining center based on particle swarm optimization and support vector regression [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2015, 45(3): 829-836.
[14] WANG Xiao-yan,SHEN Gui-xiang,ZHANG Ying-zhi,
SUN Shu-guang,QI Xiao-yan,RONG Feng. Dependent coefficient model for complex system based on failure chains [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2015, 45(2): 442-447.
[15] ZHAO Guo-juan, ZHANG Lei, LU Lei, HAN Fei-fei, ZHAO Ji. Modeling and analysis of the volumetric errors of four-axis polishing platform [J]. 吉林大学学报(工学版), 2014, 44(6): 1676-1683.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!
Copyright © Journal of Jilin University(Engineering and Technology Edition), All Rights Reserved.
Tel: +86-431-85095297　Fax: +86-431-85094074　E-mail: xbgxb@jlu.edu.cn
Powered by Beijing Magtech Co. Ltd